Top Ten Tuesday is an original feature/weekly meme created at The Broke and the Bookish. Each week they will post a new Top Ten list that one of our bloggers over at The Broke and the Bookish will answer. Everyone is welcome to join.
This week: Top Ten Best/Worst Movie AdaptationsBest:
1. Harry Potter
Although the books will always be better in my eyes, I loved the movie adaptions. My favourites are movie 1 and 4, I love the first introduction to magic in 1 and all the action in 4. I was disappointed in movie 5 and 7.1, they were quite boring and did not live up to the books. I would have liked it more if 7 would have been one movie.
2. Lord of the Rings
I liked the books, but I loved the movies! The books were a bit too tedious for my taste, but the movies were a lot faster (even though they were still three hours) and still true to the books.
3. Pride and Prejudice
I think this adaption of P&P with Keira Knightly is the best one out there. The actor whose name I forgot was exactly how I pictured Darcy in the book, dark and brooding :) If you like classic novel adaptions, I could also recommend Jane Eyre (with Michael Fassbender), North and South (with Richard Armitage) and Sense and Sensibility (with Kate Winslet), all great!
4. The Perks of being a Wallflower
I was pleasantly surprised by this adaption. It really captured the essence of the book and the actors were perfectly cast.
5. Romeo and Juliet
I really loved this movie! I have read Romeo and Juliet, but I have to admit it's quite difficult to read. The movie solved this problem. I absolutely love the starcrossed lovers story and I think Leonardo diCaprio and Claire Danes were perfectly cast.
I'm curious to see if the new version with Douglas Booth is as good as this version (think not).
I would have added the Avengers, but I did not know whether comic books classified as 'books'.
Worst:
1. The Host
This movie revolved way more around the romance than in the book. This was at the expense of the actual story and the sci-fi elements, which I found more interesting. Around three quarters of the movie consisted of kissing and the love-square, quite a disappointment.
2. I am Number Four
Alex Pettyfer just can't act. Every movie with him is just a disappointment. Sorry if you're a fan, but I just don't like him as an actor.
3. Percy Jackson
I really liked the books, but I was disappointed by the movie. I felt like they changed the whole story.
4. The Hunger Games
I'm not sure what I did not like about this movie, but it just did not blow me away like the book. Maybe it's just that my expectations were too high. I also felt like they changed too much, like Madge being cut out and the emphasis on the love triangle.
5. Twilight
I actually liked the books, except New Moon, that one was just depressing. But the movies.. no. Not sure if it's just the fact that I find Kristin Stewart fairly irritating or that the movies are really bad, but I just did not like them. I have to say the books are better than most people think, they just got a bad reputation after the movies.
Leave me a link to your top ten!
Good list, I loved Perks of Being a Wallflower and Harry Potter as well. I thought that Percy Jackson was adaption as well and I think that Twilight is just a horrible movie overall because it's just badly made.
ReplyDeleteI totally forgot about Perks of Being a Wallflower! I think they did a great job with that adaptation
ReplyDeleteGreat list - I still really need to read Perks of Being a Wallflower and I won't watch it until I have! Totally agree with your comments on Romeo and Juliet too, it made my list :)
ReplyDeleteMy TTT!
We share a few books between our lists! Perks is one I definitely want to get to soon. Great list! My TTT.
ReplyDeleteVyki @ On The Shelf
Agree with Perks of Being a Wallflower and Pride and Prejudice (although I like the BBC version better with Colin Firth). I actually loved The Host. I agree, it was missing a lot (and it felt like insta-love in the movie but it didn't in the book) but I still really enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed Romeo + Juliet. Need to watch it again!
ReplyDeleteHarry Potter! <3 I forgot to put The Host on my list but totally agree with you on that one!
ReplyDeleteMy TTT
Ally @ Book Fixation
We have very similar tastes! I was wavering on Romeo + Juliet but didn't include it on my list since I avoided anything that started life as a play; it is an incredible adaptation though.
ReplyDeleteGreat list (and I agree that Macfayden is a perfect Mr. Darcy).
Erin @ YA Book Crush
Oh man, now I'm scared to watch The Host! I loved the book so much and I was really looking forward to watching the film. Hopefully I won't be too disappointed. Thanks for stopping by my top ten :)
ReplyDeleteKelly @ Dandelion Dreams
Lol, feel the same away about Alex Pettyfer. I didn't enjoy his performance in Beastly either. Thanks for stopping by my TTT
ReplyDeleteAgreed about Percy Jackson - I'm hoping that the sequel will be better.
ReplyDeleteI really liked ROMEO + JULIET with Leonardo diCaprio and Claire Danes too. They were excellent!
Fabulous top ten!
I can't stand that Romeo and Juliet adaptation. Just not my cup of tea. The Keira Knightley P&P, though? Love it! The actor is a wonderful Mr. Darcy! As for Percy Jackson, the changes were NOT for the better.
ReplyDeleteGreat list, Eveline! :)
I LOVED the Romeo & Juliet adaptation!!! GREAT choice! But I did like The Host too haha. Much better than the Twilight films! And you are right about Percy Jackson- they DID change the whole story. Which sucked because there were a lot of awesome actors in it!
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by my blog!
-Sonnie @ ParaDays
Ahh, our lists were very similar. I never saw the Host and I'm afraid to watch it b/c I really enjoyed the book.
ReplyDeleteGreat list!
Jess @ www.suchanovelidea.com
I totally agree with the list! I am Number Four was so lame. I have yet to read the book but I sure hope it's way better than the movie.
ReplyDeleteAnd I see you liked HP4; so did I! I saw a lot of 'HP4 is the worst movie' statements today and I totally disagree; it was one of the best ones. ;)
And yay on THG, we rock, haha :D
Thanks for stopping by!
I was mad that Madge was cut too, but I still loved The Hunger Games.
ReplyDeleteMy favourite HP was 3. Gary Oldman!
My Top Ten
I second I Am Number Four!
ReplyDeleteLol, our TTT are kinda the same!! Great minds think alike and great picks this week!!
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by!
I still need to see The Host. Thanks for stopping by my post earlier. Great list.
ReplyDeleteSandy @ Somewhere Only We Know
I too was disappointed with Twilight, and while I didn't hate it I think the casting was terrible. And totally agree with you about Harry Potter - the first one was so successful at capturing the magic that the book created!
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by :)
Totally agree with you about Harry Potter - the first one was so successful at capturing the magic that the book created!
I didn't watch all movies on your list simply because I am afraid they will destroy the magic of the book.
ReplyDeleteThe Host has a love SQUARE? -runs far far far away from the book-
ReplyDeleteAnd I kind of agree with you on The Hunger Games. Maybe it's because we imagined it a lot better while we were reading the book. Who knows? o:
Great list Eveline & thanks for stopping by my TTT! (:
I think The Lord of the Rings is the best movie adaption out there. Period. =) And I totally agree with you about Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief, they changed the whole thing =/
ReplyDeleteGreat list! I forgot about Romeo and Juliet, but yes, definitely a great adaptation! And I Am Four? Completely forgot about that movie... but that's probably part of the reason it's so bad. Not memorable at all...
ReplyDelete